Discussionu/Sam Taylor·5mo ago

Super clone vs genuine - my honest take after 2 years

I've owned both genuine and super clone watches for 2 years now. Here's my honest take. The genuine wins on: resale value, brand prestige, movement finishing, long-term durability. The super clone wins on: price, variety, peace of mind (I don't worry about scratching it), and the ability to enjoy multiple references. For daily wear, I reach for my super clones more often. They're comfortable, they look great, and I don't stress about them. For special occasions or long-term investment, I wear my genuine pieces. Both have their place. It depends on what you value.

28 12 comments 521 views

12 Comments

u/Betty Clark·5mo ago

Reading this while saving up for my first one. Posts like this keep me motivated.

u/Dave Thompson·5mo ago

I usually only buy vintage, but you make a compelling case. The value equation is hard to argue with.

u/Bob Harris·5mo ago

The GMT hand jumping independently is the killer feature. I use it every time I fly.

u/Richard Moore·5mo ago

This is so sweet. I did the same for my husband last year and he still talks about it.

u/Dave Thompson·5mo ago

What was the beat error on yours? Mine came in at 0.2ms which I thought was excellent for this price point.

u/Emma Davis·5mo ago

I was skeptical about super clones for years. Posts like this finally convinced me to try one. Ordered last week.

u/Hank Williams·5mo ago

Nice! What strap are you running on it? I find the bracelet a bit heavy for summer.

u/David Kim·5mo ago

Retired as well. The research process was half the fun. Enjoy the watch!

u/Kevin O'Brien·5mo ago

I usually only buy vintage, but you make a compelling case. The value equation is hard to argue with.

u/Dana Lee·5mo ago

This is exactly my experience. The QC video is what sold me too. No other seller does that.

u/Dave Thompson·5mo ago

The chrono pushers on mine are buttery smooth. People are always surprised when I tell them.

u/Will Anderson·5mo ago

The key is the movement. Ask for a timegrapher reading before you buy.

u/Dan Wilson·5mo ago

I was skeptical about super clones for years. Posts like this finally convinced me to try one. Ordered last week.